Catégories: News


14 Oct 2015

Compensation related to duties performed can be revoked (Il Quotidiano del Lavoro – Il Sole 24 Ore, 15 october 2015)

Article written by Alberto De Luca and Giovanni Iannacchino

With its ruling no. 19465 of 2015 the Cassation Court returned to decide on the limits to the irreducibility of salary principle granted to the worker. Specifically, the Court upheld the correctness of the lower court judgement which had reiterated, in keeping with a consolidated orientation, that the irreducibility of salary principle is not absolute and does not apply to those payments given to workers aimed at compensating a specific procedure for performing their job, when that procedure changes. The case regarded a worker who was unilaterally denied the compensation paid for night shift work (as a night security guard), when his duties were changed to those of a day security guard. The worker appealing to the court against the lower court ruling, based his request on two allegations: with the first, he had denounced the violation and false application of the irreducibility of salary principle considering it absolute and not susceptible to exceptions; with the second, he had objected to the insufficient and contradictory grounds regarding a decisive fact for the judgement, consisting of  the lower court judge’s failure to consider that his salary should have been proportional to the job for which he had been hired (night shift guard) and not to that later assigned to him (day shift guard). The two motives were treated jointly and both considered unfounded. The court upheld the principle expressed by the Appellate Court whereby, once the particular procedures for performing his job no longer existed – in this case night shift work – the employer’s refusal to pay the worker a specific compensation aimed at compensating the special nature of his duties and relative hardships was completely legitimate. In keeping with a recent and consolidated case law orientation, the Supreme court argued that the irreducibility of salary principle, based on article 2103 of the Civil Code and article 36 of the Constitution, i.e. the ban on assigning lower duties and necessity for the amount of salary to be compatible with the quantity and quality of work performed, includes those payments directly connected with the special nature and more difficult manner of performing the job (most recently Labour Cassation 20418/2013 and Labour Cassation 20310/2008). The Court remarked that under this profile, the irreducibility of salary principle does not possess an absolute nature. Specifically, according to the Cassation, the salary acquired by the worker considered irreducible is that which includes all of the salary items linked to the intrinsic professional qualities of the worker’s duties. In reference to the second reason for the appeal, the Court revealed, inter alia, that in the job contract the duties indicated were those of a guard, without specifying if assigned to night or day shift. Based on the above, the Supreme court ruled that the employer’s conduct was irreproachable.

Source:

Il Quotidiano del Lavoro – Il Sole 24 Ore

Inscrivez-vous à notre lettre d’information

Contacts

Vous avez besoin d'informations ? Écrivez-nous et notre équipe d'experts vous répondra dans les plus brefs délais.

Remplissez le formulaire

Autres nouveautés et insights

13 Nov 2026

Le licenciement disciplinaire sans contestation préalable des faits reprochés entraîne la réintégration du salarié (Camera di Commercio Francese in Italia, 13 novembre 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Silvia Zulato)

Par son jugement n° 4703 du 13 octobre 2026, le Tribunal de Milan a réaffirmé que le licenciement disciplinaire prononcé sans contestation préalable des faits reprochés est illégitime…

10 Nov 2026

Travail et algorithmes : repartir des droits (L’Economia – Corriere della Sera, 9 novembre 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

La pression sur les salaires, le contexte géopolitique turbulent qui crée de l’incertitude au sein des entreprises, les inconnues liées à l’intelligence artificielle. Autant d’éléments qui pourraient sembler…

2 Nov 2026

De Luca & Partners participe à « LEGALTECH IN SCENA »

De Luca & Partners participera à LEGALTECH ON STAGE, l’événement organisé par Global LegalTech Hub (GLTH), qui se tiendra le 11 novembre 2026 à Milan et réunira des…

2 Nov 2026

Arrêt n° 174/2026 de la Cour constitutionnelle : le régime d’indemnisation en cas de licenciement illégal

Par son arrêt n° 174 de 2026, déposé le 22 octobre 2026, la Cour constitutionnelle s’est à nouveau prononcée sur les conséquences financières d’un licenciement illégal, cette fois…

2 Nov 2026

Le saviez-vous ? La représentativité syndicale aux fins de la constitution d’une représentation syndicale d’entreprise (RSA) doit être appréciée au regard du secteur d’activité de l’entreprise.

Par l’arrêt n° 27541 du 22 octobre 2026, la chambre sociale de la Cour de cassation italienne a identifié les critères permettant d’apprécier la représentativité comparative au niveau…

2 Nov 2026

Pixels de suivi et responsabilité : de nouvelles normes pour les communications par courrier électronique

L’année 2026 marque un tournant important dans l’utilisation des pixels de suivi dans les communications électroniques. Avec les récentes orientations publiées par l’Autorité italienne de protection des données…