Catégories: News


14 Déc 2015

Dismissal for objective just cause – company crisis not necessary – greater profit (Il Sole 24 Ore and Il Quotidiano del Lavoro, 15 december 2015)

With its ruling no. 23620 of 18 November 2015, the Cassation Court has declared dismissal for objective just cause lawful even if not aimed at avoiding losses but rather to achieve higher profit for the company. In the case at issue, a lab technician working in a company in the private healthcare sector and accredited with the national healthcare system, challenged a dismissal. The worker felt that the elimination of her position due to a company crisis was unjustified as well as the later assignment of her duties to other colleagues, employees of the analysis and radiology laboratory. The Court and the Appellate Court upheld her appeal, sustaining that the company had not proven the need to eliminate the position of the worker and the company crisis, considering the question on the legitimacy of assigning the duties initially assigned to her to another person to be subsumed. The company challenged the decision in the Cassation Court. In the meantime, with another petition, the worker asked the judge to declare a second dismissal from the company unlawful, based on discriminatory and retaliative grounds. Both the Court and the Appellate Court granted the worker’s allegations, with arguments similar to those the previous rulings had been based on. Again in this circumstance the company appealed to the Cassation Court. Specifically, the company sustained that the reason for the worker’s dismissal was based on (i) the need, imposed by the Region, to hire a director for the analysis laboratory with a university degree in biology or chemistry and (ii) the fact that the duties assigned to her were no longer useful, plus the impossibility to give her a position in other departments due to their economic difficulties. The Cassation Court, in its decision first explained that according to case law the reasons for a dismissal must be objectively verifiable and the relative burden of proof lies with the employer. Therefore, if the employer does not meet this burden of proof, exercising organisational power must be considered unlawful due to abuse, despite business decisions being unchallengeable by the judge pursuant to article 30, paragraph 1 of Italian Law no. 183/2010 (so-called Collegato Lavoro), which is aimed at more intensive protection of a company’s organisational freedom. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court observed that the employment contract can be terminated not only to downsize production but also following a burden not foreseen at the time of hiring but emerging later on. This burden, according to the Cassation Court, may also entail “an assessment by the entrepreneur which, based on the company’s economic performance reported after the conclusion of the contract, indicates the possibility of replacing less qualified personnel with employees in possession of greater knowledge and experience and thus productive aptitudes”. According to the Supreme Court this is an exercise of assessment that cannot be verified on merit by the judge. The Cassation Court also confirmed that the judge cannot even control the aim, to enhance and not impoverish, pursued by the employer. This is because “an increase in profit does not translate, or does not only translate, into an advantage for his individual assets but mainly in an increase in the company’s profit, i.e. in a benefit for all workers”. The Court also observed that the lower court judges had erred in not verifying, once the absence of a drop in production was discovered, the assignment of the duties initially assigned to the dismissed worker to another employee with a university degree in biology. The same Court then concluded that judicial control of “the real operation of personnel reorganisation and redistribution of duties”, must also include verification of the economic difficulties of other departments, ordering that such verification be remanded to the trail judges.

Source:

Il Sole 24 Ore

Inscrivez-vous à notre lettre d’information

Contacts

Vous avez besoin d'informations ? Écrivez-nous et notre équipe d'experts vous répondra dans les plus brefs délais.

Remplissez le formulaire

Autres nouveautés et insights

13 Nov 2026

Le licenciement disciplinaire sans contestation préalable des faits reprochés entraîne la réintégration du salarié (Camera di Commercio Francese in Italia, 13 novembre 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Silvia Zulato)

Par son jugement n° 4703 du 13 octobre 2026, le Tribunal de Milan a réaffirmé que le licenciement disciplinaire prononcé sans contestation préalable des faits reprochés est illégitime…

10 Nov 2026

Travail et algorithmes : repartir des droits (L’Economia – Corriere della Sera, 9 novembre 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

La pression sur les salaires, le contexte géopolitique turbulent qui crée de l’incertitude au sein des entreprises, les inconnues liées à l’intelligence artificielle. Autant d’éléments qui pourraient sembler…

2 Nov 2026

De Luca & Partners participe à « LEGALTECH IN SCENA »

De Luca & Partners participera à LEGALTECH ON STAGE, l’événement organisé par Global LegalTech Hub (GLTH), qui se tiendra le 11 novembre 2026 à Milan et réunira des…

2 Nov 2026

Arrêt n° 174/2026 de la Cour constitutionnelle : le régime d’indemnisation en cas de licenciement illégal

Par son arrêt n° 174 de 2026, déposé le 22 octobre 2026, la Cour constitutionnelle s’est à nouveau prononcée sur les conséquences financières d’un licenciement illégal, cette fois…

2 Nov 2026

Le saviez-vous ? La représentativité syndicale aux fins de la constitution d’une représentation syndicale d’entreprise (RSA) doit être appréciée au regard du secteur d’activité de l’entreprise.

Par l’arrêt n° 27541 du 22 octobre 2026, la chambre sociale de la Cour de cassation italienne a identifié les critères permettant d’apprécier la représentativité comparative au niveau…

2 Nov 2026

Pixels de suivi et responsabilité : de nouvelles normes pour les communications par courrier électronique

L’année 2026 marque un tournant important dans l’utilisation des pixels de suivi dans les communications électroniques. Avec les récentes orientations publiées par l’Autorité italienne de protection des données…