Categories: Insights, Publications

Tag: Licenziamento


24 Jul 2019

Dismissal due to the abusive use of 104 permits and investigations (Il Quotidiano del Lavoro de Il Sole 24 Ore, 25 July 2019 – Alberto De Luca, Debhora Scarano)

The Court of Cassation, by Ruling no. 18411 dated 9 July 2019, returned to analysing the delicate issue relating to the breach of the relationship of trust, following the abuse by the worker of the permits provided for by Law no. 104/1992.

The case originates from the dismissal for just cause inflicted upon an employee for having taken two days’ leave under the provision referred to above, to care for a disabled relative, having emerged, however, from the investigations ordered by the employer that, in accordance with the permits in question, the person concerned had not left his home and, therefore, could not have gone to the separate home of his relative to provide care.

The courts on the matter, both at first instance and on appeal, dismissed the employee’s appeal, considering that the burden of proof had been met by the employer, albeit not by direct evidence but by deduction, on the basis of the combined interpretation of the investigation report – confirmed by the witness – and the oral justifications given by the employee.

In appealing to the Court of Cassation against the decision, the worker complained – amongst other reasons – that the principle of the burden of proof of the existence of a just cause for dismissal was incorrect and misapplied, noting, firstly, that the full proof of the conduct challenged by the employer had not been fulfilled, given that the investigation report revealed that the exact house number corresponding to the person cared for was unknown. He also complained that the Territorial Court had not taken into account the fact that a supplementary investigation had been carried out at a later stage after the imposition of the dismissal. The erroneous assessment of the evidentiary findings, which also arose from the lack of full proof of the disputed fact, led, in the applicant’s view, to a source of uncertainty as to the actual gravity of the conduct and, consequently, as to the proportionality of the adopted measure. The courts of law, by declaring the inadmissibility of all the pleas in law in holding that the logical reasoning of the courts on the matter was free of defects, confirmed the validity of the worker’s expulsion measure, in total acceptance of what was laid down in the ruling on the matter.

Specifically, it is specified by the Supreme Court that the local court had addressed, with logically reasonable grounds, the issue of the abuse of permits under Law No. 104/1992, noting that the investigative report produced by the employer, confirmed by witnesses and strident with respect to what was stated by the worker at the disciplinary hearing, was perfectly capable of fully demonstrating the lack of care for which said worker received permits. It seems appropriate, in relation to the matter of the examination in question, to go back over the jurisprudential guidelines which have emerged with regard to the limits within which the employer can legitimately control the workers, also taking advantage of private investigative agencies, in order to ensure the correct use of the permits referred to in Article 33, paragraph 3, of Law No. 104 of 1992.

 

Please read the full version of the article here.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Contact

Need information? Write to us and our team of experts will respond as soon as possible.

Fill in the form

More news and insights

13 Nov 2026

Disciplinary dismissal without prior notification of the allegations entails the employee’s reinstatement (Camera di Commercio Francese in Italia, 13 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Silvia Zulato)

By judgment no. 4703 of 13 October 2026, the Court of Milan reaffirmed that a disciplinary dismissal imposed without prior notification of the allegations is unlawful and, where…

10 Nov 2026

Work and algorithms: starting again from rights (L’Economia – Corriere della Sera, 9 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

Wage pressures, a turbulent geopolitical context creating uncertainty for companies, and the unknowns surrounding artificial intelligence. These may seem like pieces of the same puzzle that do not…

2 Nov 2026

De Luca & Partners participates in “LEGALTECH IN SCENA”

De Luca & Partners participated in LEGALTECH IN SCENA, an event organised by Global LegalTech Hub (GLTH), which took place in Milan on 11 November 2026 and brought…

2 Nov 2026

Constitutional Court Judgment No. 174/2026: the compensation regime for unlawful dismissals 

With Judgment No. 174 of 2026, filed on 22 October 2026, the Constitutional Court once again addressed the financial consequences of unlawful dismissal, this time in relation to…

2 Nov 2026

Did you know that… trade union representativeness for the purpose of establishing a workplace union representation (RSA) must be assessed within the company’s sector of activity?  

With judgment no. 27541 of 22 October 2026, the Employment Section of the Italian Supreme Court identified the criteria for assessing the comparative representativeness at national level of…

2 Nov 2026

Tracking pixels and accountability: new standards for email communications 

The year 2026 marks a significant shift in the way tracking pixels are used in electronic communications. With the recent guidance issued by the Italian Data Protection Authority…