Unlawful dismissal for just cause (Modulo 24 Contenzioso Lavoro de Il Sole 24 Ore, 22 February 2024 – Enrico De Luca, Raffaele Di Vuolo)

Employment relationship – Dismissal for just cause – Unlawfulness – Existence

The existence of wilful and negligent misconduct to the detriment of the employer company requires that the damage be a foreseeable consequence of the employee’s conduct. In light of this principle, the dismissal of an employee who, having been authorised to leave the workplace during working hours, stopped on the way to the market for a few minutes in the company car, was held to be unlawful. At that time, he was photographed and the photo was published on the social media site Facebook, gathering the indignation of several subscribers. Italian Court of Cassation, Employment Division, 6 December 2023, no. 34107. The Court of Cassation, Employment Division, with judgment no. 34107 of 6 December 2023 ruled that the dismissal of an employee who, having been authorised to go home in the company car to change his wet clothes, stops on the way to go shopping at the market is unlawful. In the context of the evaluations carried out by the local court and confirmed by the Court of Cassation, the filming and subsequent publication of the company car by an extraneous third party was irrelevant for the purposes of assessing the lawfulness of the dismissal. This triggered the indignation of social media subscribers. In fact, it had emerged in the course of the proceedings that the employee’s conduct, not constituting conduct committed wilfully or negligently to the detriment of the company, was to be classified as unauthorised absence from the workplace for the sole period of the stop at the market. The Court concluded that such a case, also in the light of the provisions of the collective bargaining agreement applicable in that instance, should have been sanctioned with a precautionary measure.