Categories: Insights

6 Apr 2010

Dismissal and failed challenge within the terms: the Court of Cassation changes its orientation (Court of Cassation, Labour Section, no. 2676/2010)

The Court of Cassation changed its prevailing stance on the compensation effect of the present missed challenge of dismissal, determining that if the judge can no longer ascertain whether or not the dismissal is legitimate, he must consider preservation of compensation also blocked. Breach indeed constitutes a precondition of compensation due by the defaulting contracting party pursuant to art. 1218 of the Italian Civil Code. The impossibility of said ascertainment rules out the possibility to reconnect the compensating obligation in favour of the worker to the alleged breach of the employer. This is true regardless of the individual or collective nature of the dismissal. The case examined by the Court regarded a group of workers that had applied to the Court for the Company that had employed them to be sentenced to indemnify and compensate for the damage pursuant to art. 18 of the workers’ statute of rights or, subordinately and alternative, to compensate the damage deriving from the dismissal according to the ordinary civil law principles. These workers however had not challenged the dismissal within the terms set forth in the regulations on the subject (impugnment that the special laws contemplate must be carried out within 60 days from notification of the dismissal).
Subscribe to our newsletter

Contact

Need information? Write to us and our team of experts will respond as soon as possible.

Fill in the form

More news and insights

13 Jul 2026

Cautious, yet moving forward (Business People, 13 luglio 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

In Business People, our Managing Partner, Vittorio De Luca, discusses a business landscape that is cautious, yet far from standing still—one that is rethinking processes, skills, and management…

Read more
8 Jul 2026

Pay transparency: one month after its entry into force, two approaches are emerging in the market (The Platform, 8 July 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Claudia Cerbone e Martina De Angeli)

Since 7 June, EU rules aimed at strengthening the principle of equal pay between men and women for the same work or for work of equal value have…

Read more
2 Jul 2026

Did you know…? As of 7 June 2026, Legislative Decree No. 96/2026 is fully in force

As of 7 June 2026, Legislative Decree No. 96/2026 is fully in force. It also introduces into the Italian legal system a structured framework on pay transparency, with…

Read more
2 Jul 2026

Failure to serve disciplinary charges does not render the dismissal null and void: italian supreme court confirms no reinstatement remedy for employers below the statutory workforce threshold

Principle of Law In its recent judgment No. 17283 of 1 June 2026, the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) examined the legal consequences arising from the employer's…

Read more
2 Jul 2026

AI and the employment relationship: initial guidance from the implementing decrees and data protection implications

Following the preliminary approval by the Council of Ministers, on 10 June 2026, of the first draft legislative decrees implementing the enabling law on artificial intelligence (Law No.…

Read more
1 Jul 2026

Sustainability, Responsibility, and the Future: A Commitment That Grows with Time

As we celebrate our 50th anniversary, we have chosen to look to the future with the same care and dedication with which we preserve our roots. Those roots…

Read more