Categories: Insights, Legislation

Tag: account di posta aziendale, controlli datoriali, Dismissal


31 Jul 2023

Italian Court of Cassation: Defence checks on employee’s company e-mail

By judgment No. 18168 of 26 June 2023, the Italian Court of Cassation once again addressed the issue of the limits of employer controls via the use of IT tools, establishing the unlawfulness of dismissal and the non-usability of evidence gathered following a check on an employee’s company e-mail carried out by the employer company in breach of, inter alia, the provisions on the protection of personal data.

The facts of the case

The procedural case stems from a disciplinary measure against a worker for ‘insubordinate conduct and breach of the duties of diligence and loyalty as well as of the general principles of fairness and good faith’ because, among other things, he had had dealings with competitors.

The evidence relating to the alleged facts had been collected following an indiscriminate investigation carried out by the company into the company email assigned to the worker.

The Court of Appeal, in upholding the first instance ruling, found that the dismissal was unlawful and ordered the company to pay sums in lieu of notice supplementary indemnity, and as amounts due as severance pay (TFR)

The unsuccessful company thus appealed to the Italian Court of Cassation.

‘Defensive controls’

On this occasion, the Court of Cassation once again returned to the issue of so-called ‘defensive controls’, reaffirming the distinction between a. ‘controls in defence of the company’s assets’ and b. ‘defensive controls in the strict sense’.

a. The ‘controls in defence of company assets’

The ‘controls in defence of company assets’ concern all employees (or groups of employees) who in carrying out their work are in contact with company assets and must necessarily be carried out in compliance with, and within the limits of, the provisions of Article 4 of the Italian Workers’ Statute (Italian Law No. 300/70).

b. ‘Defensive controls in the strict sense’

The ‘defensive controls in the strict sense’, on the other hand, are aimed at ascertaining specific unlawful conduct attributable, on the basis of specific indications, to individual workers and ‘remain, even today, outside the scope of application of Article 4’; these controls must be targeted and implemented ex post, prompted, therefore, by episodes that have already occurred ‘because only from that point onwards the employer can collect usable information’.

The decision of the Italian Court of Cassation

Returning to the present case, the Court of Appeal found that the company:

  • had not given reasons justifying access to and monitoring of the e-mail inbox;
  • had carried out its investigations ‘indiscriminately [on] all communications on the company PC in use’ without, inter alia, establishing a time limit for the search;
  • had not proved that he had informed the worker in advance of the possibility that his communications might be monitored nor ‘of the nature and extent of the monitoring or the level of intrusion in his correspondence’;
  • had engaged in such conduct without complying with the company regulations governing the use of company e-mails.

Since it is not possible ‘to remove the worker’s relationship with his employer from the general rules on the protection of personal data’, the Italian Court of Cassation itself – which refers to the founding principles of the matter including (i) the principles of minimisation and proportionality (ii) the principles of relevance and non-excessiveness with respect to a lawful purpose as well as (iii) the principles of transparency and fairness – clarifies that even in the context of a ‘defensive control in the strict sense’ it is necessary to ensure ‘a correct balance between the employer’s needs to protect the company’s assets and property and the indispensable protection of the worker’s dignity and confidentiality’.

For all these reasons, the Court concludes, the second instance judges correctly assessed the balance between the conduct engaged in by the company and the resulting level of intrusion into the worker’s private life.

The Italian Court of Cassation rejected the appeal, finding against the appellant company and upholding the unlawfulness of the dismissal as well as the unusability of the unlawfully acquired data.

The Italian Court of Cassation indicated the elements useful for guiding the Italian judge’s balancing act in cases of ‘defensive checks in the strict sense’:

By referring to the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (specifically, the case Barbulescu v. Romania, 5 September 2017), the Italian Court of Cassation indicated the elements useful for guiding the Italian judge’s balancing act in cases of ‘defensive checks in the strict sense’:

  • informing the worker about the possibility of the employer taking monitoring measures;
  • the level of intrusion into the private sphere of employees, taking into account, inter alia, the more or less private nature of the place in which monitoring takes place, the spatial and temporal limits of the monitoring, and the number of persons who have access to its results;
  • the existence of a justification for the use of surveillance and its extension on lawful grounds;
  • the assessment, based on the specific circumstances of each case, of whether the lawful purpose pursued by the employer could be achieved by causing a lower level of invasion of privacy;
  • verification of how the employer used the results and whether they served the stated purpose;
  • the provision of adequate guarantees to the employee on the level of intrusion of the surveillance measures.

Other related insights:

Subscribe to our newsletter

Contact

Need information? Write to us and our team of experts will respond as soon as possible.

Fill in the form

More news and insights

13 Nov 2026

Disciplinary dismissal without prior notification of the allegations entails the employee’s reinstatement (Camera di Commercio Francese in Italia, 13 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Silvia Zulato)

By judgment no. 4703 of 13 October 2026, the Court of Milan reaffirmed that a disciplinary dismissal imposed without prior notification of the allegations is unlawful and, where…

10 Nov 2026

Work and algorithms: starting again from rights (L’Economia – Corriere della Sera, 9 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

Wage pressures, a turbulent geopolitical context creating uncertainty for companies, and the unknowns surrounding artificial intelligence. These may seem like pieces of the same puzzle that do not…

2 Nov 2026

De Luca & Partners participates in “LEGALTECH IN SCENA”

De Luca & Partners participated in LEGALTECH IN SCENA, an event organised by Global LegalTech Hub (GLTH), which took place in Milan on 11 November 2026 and brought…

2 Nov 2026

Constitutional Court Judgment No. 174/2026: the compensation regime for unlawful dismissals 

With Judgment No. 174 of 2026, filed on 22 October 2026, the Constitutional Court once again addressed the financial consequences of unlawful dismissal, this time in relation to…

2 Nov 2026

Did you know that… trade union representativeness for the purpose of establishing a workplace union representation (RSA) must be assessed within the company’s sector of activity?  

With judgment no. 27541 of 22 October 2026, the Employment Section of the Italian Supreme Court identified the criteria for assessing the comparative representativeness at national level of…

2 Nov 2026

Tracking pixels and accountability: new standards for email communications 

The year 2026 marks a significant shift in the way tracking pixels are used in electronic communications. With the recent guidance issued by the Italian Data Protection Authority…