Categories: Insights, Case Law · News, Publications

Tag: Corte di Cassazione


30 Jan 2023

Reclassification of the self-employment relationship even in the absence of direct evidence of employer direction

The Italian Court of Cassation, by order No 1095 of 16 January 2023, held that for the purpose of reclassifying a relationship of self-employment into a subordinate one, it is possible to use subsidiary evidence (such as the continuity of service, compliance with a predetermined schedule, the receipt of a fixed monthly fee, the absence of risk and an organisational structure on the part of the worker) where there is no direct evidence of employer direction.

The facts of the case

The Supreme Court’s decision arises from proceedings brought by an IT consultant who had worked under multiple consecutive self-employment contracts, on behalf of the principal, as a system assistant at the judicial offices of Arezzo.

The Court of Pisa, in the first instance, had rejected the application for reclassification, confirming the self-employment nature of the relationship in the absence of proof of the employer’s direction.

The worker appealed against this decision before the Florence Court of Appeal complaining that the first-instance judge had not given enough importance to all the evidence that, although not sufficient to demonstrate employer direction, was sufficient to constitute proof of the subordinate relationship between them.

In the context of the second instance judgment, the territorial Court, overturning the decision of the first instance judge, held that there was an employment relationship based on the following evidence:

  • the self-employment contracts (called consulting assignments) covered the details of the services to be provided by the collaborator in a completely generic way. Thus, notwithstanding the express classification of the relationship as self-employed, the wording of the contracts did not contain any elements contradicting the existence of a subordinate relationship, which, on the contrary, was confirmed by the stipulation of remuneration commensurate with the number of working days;
  • the worker used work equipment provided by the principal, with the consequent absence of financial risk on the part of the service provider;
  • the principal exercised control over the employee’s hourly and daily workload, who performed his services according to the company’s needs;
  • entirely similar functions were entrusted, at another judicial office, to a technician employed by the company.

The company appealed against the judgment of the Court of Appeal before the Italian Court of Cassation.

The Italian Court of Cassation’s decision

The Italian Court of Cassation rejected the appeal, confirming that the Court of Appeal, having failed to find direct evidence of so-called ‘employer direction’, had correctly resorted to circumstantial evidence which, in this case, constituted suitable and significant evidence of a para-subordinate relationship.

Therefore, even in the absence of employer direction, the Court of appeal found that the existence of a subordinate relationship had been proved as (i) there was control over the hourly and daily workload; (ii) the remuneration was commensurate with the working days; (iii) the employee had no financial risk; (iv) the employee performed his services at the requested times; (v) the generic details of the services to be provided under the collaboration indicated in the contract and the absence of an obligation to achieve results.

In view of all the above, the Italian Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal filed by the company and ordered it to pay the litigation costs.

Other related insights:

Subscribe to our newsletter

Contact

Need information? Write to us and our team of experts will respond as soon as possible.

Fill in the form

More news and insights

13 Nov 2026

Disciplinary dismissal without prior notification of the allegations entails the employee’s reinstatement (Camera di Commercio Francese in Italia, 13 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca, Silvia Zulato)

By judgment no. 4703 of 13 October 2026, the Court of Milan reaffirmed that a disciplinary dismissal imposed without prior notification of the allegations is unlawful and, where…

10 Nov 2026

Work and algorithms: starting again from rights (L’Economia – Corriere della Sera, 9 November 2026 – Vittorio De Luca)

Wage pressures, a turbulent geopolitical context creating uncertainty for companies, and the unknowns surrounding artificial intelligence. These may seem like pieces of the same puzzle that do not…

2 Nov 2026

De Luca & Partners participates in “LEGALTECH IN SCENA”

De Luca & Partners participated in LEGALTECH IN SCENA, an event organised by Global LegalTech Hub (GLTH), which took place in Milan on 11 November 2026 and brought…

2 Nov 2026

Constitutional Court Judgment No. 174/2026: the compensation regime for unlawful dismissals 

With Judgment No. 174 of 2026, filed on 22 October 2026, the Constitutional Court once again addressed the financial consequences of unlawful dismissal, this time in relation to…

2 Nov 2026

Did you know that… trade union representativeness for the purpose of establishing a workplace union representation (RSA) must be assessed within the company’s sector of activity?  

With judgment no. 27541 of 22 October 2026, the Employment Section of the Italian Supreme Court identified the criteria for assessing the comparative representativeness at national level of…

2 Nov 2026

Tracking pixels and accountability: new standards for email communications 

The year 2026 marks a significant shift in the way tracking pixels are used in electronic communications. With the recent guidance issued by the Italian Data Protection Authority…