Repêchage does not oblige relocation to inferior tasks incompatible with the worker’s profile (Norme & Tributi Plus Lavoro de Il Sole 24 Ore, 3 February 2025 – Vittorio De Luca, Alesia Hima)
The Court of Cassation, with Order No. 1364 of 20 January 2025, clarified important aspects relating to the obligation of repêchage in the event of dismissal for justified objective reasons. In particular, the Court of Cassation – excluding the reinstatement of the employee – ruled that the obligation of repêchage does not require the employer to relocate the employee to lower tasks in the workforce if there are no tasks compatible with the dismissed employee’s professional profile.
The case originates from an appeal brought by an employee, who held the position of export salesman, who was dismissed following the cancellation of his position. Challenging the dismissal, the worker claimed that the company had not adequately explored all the possibilities of outplacement within the company, thus requesting reinstatement.
In the course of the proceedings, the Court of First Instance had held that the dismissal was unlawful from a procedural point of view, and had also recognised that the repêchage obligation had not been complied with. However, the Supreme Court, reforming the first instance ruling, established that the search for alternative duties should not extend to positions that are not strictly compatible with the employee’s professionalism.
The Piaggio case clearly illustrates how the same set of facts can give rise to profoundly different assessments depending on the perspective adopted. In its decision of 13…
Headnote In its recent judgment No. 24981 of 3 September 2026, the Italian Supreme Court held that, where a dismissal is set aside with an order of reinstatement…
The Italian Supreme Court, Labour Section, by order no. 25687 of 22 September 2026, addressed the issue of the disciplinary relevance of statements made by an employee in…
The spread of artificial intelligence tools used without corporate authorization exposes businesses to risks involving personal data, confidential information, know-how, and cybersecurity. To govern Shadow AI, organizations need…
Interpretative issues in light of the most recent case law on the nullity of non-compete agreements due to the indeterminacy of territorial scope By an order issued on…
The Italian Supreme Court (Labour Section), in Order No. 25231 of 11 September 2026, upheld the lawfulness of the dismissal for just cause of a store manager who…